Risk assessment plays a crucial role in pharmaceutical validation as it enables the ascertainment of different process stages, machinery processes, systems, and qualities that require the most attention. The tools used for validation risk analysis available in pharmaceutical industries include failure mode and effect analysis, failure mode, effects, and criticality analysis, fault tree analysis, hazard analysis, and critical control point analysis, hazard operability analysis, preliminary hazard analysis, and risk ranking and filtering.
The checklists and tools mentioned above allow for correct QRM by following a methodical way of producing decisions. They are applied in process validation, cleaning validation, equipment qualification, utility qualification, and systems validation and during any activities for which it is necessary to analyze product quality and patient safety.
The idea is not to work out a risk rating for each procedure but to find reasonable threats, forecast their consequences, and define scientifically supported countermeasures.
A typical FMEA sheet consists of the following components:
As an illustration, the process validation of the tablet compression process may foresee a potential failure condition of weight variation in tablets due to uncontrolled powder supply. In this respect, the assessment may involve examining the ensuing impact on dose uniformity and identifying why this may happen (for example, granules flow characteristics, feeder settings), as well as controls (e.g. in-process weight checks, process parameters monitoring).
The assessment will allow one to determine which of the parameters need close monitoring during validation batch processes and what evidence should be collected during that time.
It is important to use FMECA in case there is a production line with varied failure modes that have to be arranged in order of significance. The analysis yields an evaluation of important steps of operations, the functions of certain devices, and control measures used.
For example, the failure modes of a fluid bed dryer in a pharmaceutical plant may include insufficient airflow, wrong temperature recording, filter blockage, and malfunctions of the exhaust system. The implementation of FMECA will help assess the impact of each of these failures on drying performance, product characteristics, and control of technology.
The derived priority should be based on technical understanding and documented considerations. It is important to point out that criticality does not mean that the reconsideration and investigation of the failure should not be carried out.
This technique of FTA is very useful when dealing with complicated systems as the occurrence of failure might happen due to the interaction of several causes.
Let us consider the example of “The pharmaceutical purified water that does not fulfill the microbiological acceptance criteria” as a top-level event leading to the fault tree analysis. This event may unfold several scenarios, namely:
i. Insufficient cleaning
ii. Abuse of equipment
iii. Unfavorable working condition
iv. Problems connected to sampling
All these scenarios can be evaluated as the hypotheses and not the marked problems that are automatically utilized as the causes for the failure. When dealing with the fault tree analysis, it becomes possible to improve the investigation process and identify the measures necessary for improvement.
The main parts of HACCP include the analysis of hazards, ascribing critical control points where necessary, setting critical limits, monitoring and monitoring, making corrections if the principles are broken, verifying the data and recording the information obtained.
HACCP can be utilized in the pharmaceutical industry in the assessment of the risks connected with contamination processes in manufacturing, water systems and aseptic processing. It should be based on a sufficient understanding of the processes.
For instance, in the aseptic process the team should be able to identify possible pathways for microbial contamination and implement measures for their control as well as their monitoring and verification.
No critical control point should be declared a crucial one only because the processing step seems to be important. There should be sufficient scientific reason to call it this way, and the point should be aligned with the control strategy of the site and its procedures.
HAZOP has been found useful when applied to processes with complex equipment and utilities.
In case of purified water distribution loop, HAZOP may assess defects like:
HAZOP is most effective when it is used together with process flow diagrams and piping and instrumentation diagrams along with knowledgeable personnel.
PHA can help conduct timely validation planning of a new facility, equipment installation, process, or utility. As design and process understanding progress, the assessment may need refinement by means of a more advanced tool.
Risk ranking and filtering become necessary when many things have to be evaluated, and resources are to be prioritized. For instance, equipment in a facility can be ranked based on its consequence in terms of product quality, patient safety, and data integrity.
The criteria should be defined beforehand. Otherwise, the risk ranking exercise can turn from an objective list into a subjective one, where participants assign ratings without observing their reasoning.
Though these examples help illustrate the classification of methods, it should be noted that there is no unique regulatory prescription assigned. The use of more than one method is acceptable and desirable whenever their use bear fruit.
Reviewers need to verify if the team took into account valid sources of failure, the pertinent quality characteristics of the product, the effect on patients, the current controls, and the reasons behind risk grades. The assessment must name the actions to take, responsible people, timelines, and the process to verify implementation.
One of the most typical mistakes is evaluation of risk as low because of the unlikeliness of occurrence but ignoring the impact of the possible consequences. Another mistake is when the score for risk assessment is decreased through the detection of control without checking its credibility and possibility of failing detection.
Reassessment of risk evaluations is important whenever new information is obtained, for example, significant deviations, change control protocol, failure of validation process, audit reminder, or evidence indicating that an assumption has lost its validity. One of the key points of the ICH Q9(R1) is that risk evaluation is part of the quality risk management process, and that it needs to be done on constant basis.
During an inspection, the evaluation should be reviewed to understand the rationale of some of the steps taken, such as selection of validation parameters, sampling sites, or controls taken. The rationale should be described in detail enough for the other competent analyst to follow the steps taken.
The process of risk assessment provides a structured approach to making decisions in pharmaceutical validation, but the quality of the process is dependent on understanding the process, having sufficient evidence, and having a knowledgeable team. Tools like FMEA and FMECA are useful for ranking the failure modes, while FTA is needed to trace complex causes, HACCP is intended to deal with hazard prevention, and HAZOP helps to track the process aberrations. Choosing the right risk assessment tool, taking care of justification, and following up on risk as knowledge changes makes the risk assessment process worth it within a GMP environment.
The checklists and tools mentioned above allow for correct QRM by following a methodical way of producing decisions. They are applied in process validation, cleaning validation, equipment qualification, utility qualification, and systems validation and during any activities for which it is necessary to analyze product quality and patient safety.
The idea is not to work out a risk rating for each procedure but to find reasonable threats, forecast their consequences, and define scientifically supported countermeasures.
FMEA: A Practical Tool for Validation Planning
FMEA is one of the most popular risk assessment tools in the medication validation process. It considers the potential failure modes and related effects, possible causes, and measures taken.A typical FMEA sheet consists of the following components:
- A process step or a system operation
- Possible failure mechanism
- Possible failure consequences
- Possible cause of failure
- Preventive means in place for failure and detection measures
- The severity of the failure, its occurrence, and detection level
- Risk priority or action decision
- Recommended preventive measures and person in charge along with the completion of the task
As an illustration, the process validation of the tablet compression process may foresee a potential failure condition of weight variation in tablets due to uncontrolled powder supply. In this respect, the assessment may involve examining the ensuing impact on dose uniformity and identifying why this may happen (for example, granules flow characteristics, feeder settings), as well as controls (e.g. in-process weight checks, process parameters monitoring).
The assessment will allow one to determine which of the parameters need close monitoring during validation batch processes and what evidence should be collected during that time.
FMECA: Prioritizing Critical Failure Modes
FMECA, which stands for Failure Mode, Effects and Criticality Analysis, is an enhancement of the earlier concept FMEA. While studying the modes of failure with respect to their effects, it evaluates them systematically in the context of criticality.It is important to use FMECA in case there is a production line with varied failure modes that have to be arranged in order of significance. The analysis yields an evaluation of important steps of operations, the functions of certain devices, and control measures used.
For example, the failure modes of a fluid bed dryer in a pharmaceutical plant may include insufficient airflow, wrong temperature recording, filter blockage, and malfunctions of the exhaust system. The implementation of FMECA will help assess the impact of each of these failures on drying performance, product characteristics, and control of technology.
The derived priority should be based on technical understanding and documented considerations. It is important to point out that criticality does not mean that the reconsideration and investigation of the failure should not be carried out.
Fault Tree Analysis: Identifying the Initiators of a Failure
The technique of Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) is a type of method in which one starts with an undesirable circumstance and works backwards toward finding the eventual causes and combinations of events. Logical operators such as AND and OR are employed in determining if there is any relation between events.This technique of FTA is very useful when dealing with complicated systems as the occurrence of failure might happen due to the interaction of several causes.
Let us consider the example of “The pharmaceutical purified water that does not fulfill the microbiological acceptance criteria” as a top-level event leading to the fault tree analysis. This event may unfold several scenarios, namely:
i. Insufficient cleaning
ii. Abuse of equipment
iii. Unfavorable working condition
iv. Problems connected to sampling
All these scenarios can be evaluated as the hypotheses and not the marked problems that are automatically utilized as the causes for the failure. When dealing with the fault tree analysis, it becomes possible to improve the investigation process and identify the measures necessary for improvement.
HACCP: Managing Process and Contamination Hazards
HACCP (Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points) is a systematic and preventive approach to the identification and assessment of hazards in processes. The system concerns itself mainly with biological, chemical and physical hazards.The main parts of HACCP include the analysis of hazards, ascribing critical control points where necessary, setting critical limits, monitoring and monitoring, making corrections if the principles are broken, verifying the data and recording the information obtained.
HACCP can be utilized in the pharmaceutical industry in the assessment of the risks connected with contamination processes in manufacturing, water systems and aseptic processing. It should be based on a sufficient understanding of the processes.
For instance, in the aseptic process the team should be able to identify possible pathways for microbial contamination and implement measures for their control as well as their monitoring and verification.
No critical control point should be declared a crucial one only because the processing step seems to be important. There should be sufficient scientific reason to call it this way, and the point should be aligned with the control strategy of the site and its procedures.
HAZOP: Assessing Deviations in Process Conditions
HAZOP is an analytical method used for identifying deviations that take place during the operations of any process. In most cases, some common terms are used in this method which include guide words such as: No, More, Less, Reverse and Other than.HAZOP has been found useful when applied to processes with complex equipment and utilities.
In case of purified water distribution loop, HAZOP may assess defects like:
- No flow or flow being lower than the intended
- Temperature being greater than intended
- Pressure being incorrect
- Flow reversal
- Some sort of chemical and microbial contamination.
HAZOP is most effective when it is used together with process flow diagrams and piping and instrumentation diagrams along with knowledgeable personnel.
Preliminary Hazard Assessment and Risk Ranking
Preliminary Hazard Assessment (PHA) is a technique that is particularly useful at different stages of a project when detailed design information is not yet available. The analysis reveals likely hazards, their possible outcomes, and some risk controls possible at early stages of project execution.PHA can help conduct timely validation planning of a new facility, equipment installation, process, or utility. As design and process understanding progress, the assessment may need refinement by means of a more advanced tool.
Risk ranking and filtering become necessary when many things have to be evaluated, and resources are to be prioritized. For instance, equipment in a facility can be ranked based on its consequence in terms of product quality, patient safety, and data integrity.
The criteria should be defined beforehand. Otherwise, the risk ranking exercise can turn from an objective list into a subjective one, where participants assign ratings without observing their reasoning.
Selecting the Right Tool for a Validation Activity
The right tool is no single tool; each tool used in a validation process is dictated by the complexity of the process, type of hazard involved, what is known about the hazard so far, and what would the final decision be.| Types of validation process | Example of tools |
| Process validation planning | FMEA or FMECA |
| Risk evaluation of cleaning validation | FMEA, HACCP or risk ranking |
| Qualification of equipment | FMEA or HAZOP |
| Assessment of utility systems | HAZOP, FTA or FMEA |
| Investigation of a complicated failure | Fault Tree Analysis |
| Early project hazard identification | Preliminary Hazard Analysis |
| Setting priorities for equipment or systems | Risk ranking and filtering |
Though these examples help illustrate the classification of methods, it should be noted that there is no unique regulatory prescription assigned. The use of more than one method is acceptable and desirable whenever their use bear fruit.
What QA Should Verify in a Risk Assessment
When it comes to QA, the top question is whether the assessment is scientifically valid and justifies the intended validation plan.Reviewers need to verify if the team took into account valid sources of failure, the pertinent quality characteristics of the product, the effect on patients, the current controls, and the reasons behind risk grades. The assessment must name the actions to take, responsible people, timelines, and the process to verify implementation.
One of the most typical mistakes is evaluation of risk as low because of the unlikeliness of occurrence but ignoring the impact of the possible consequences. Another mistake is when the score for risk assessment is decreased through the detection of control without checking its credibility and possibility of failing detection.
Reassessment of risk evaluations is important whenever new information is obtained, for example, significant deviations, change control protocol, failure of validation process, audit reminder, or evidence indicating that an assumption has lost its validity. One of the key points of the ICH Q9(R1) is that risk evaluation is part of the quality risk management process, and that it needs to be done on constant basis.
During an inspection, the evaluation should be reviewed to understand the rationale of some of the steps taken, such as selection of validation parameters, sampling sites, or controls taken. The rationale should be described in detail enough for the other competent analyst to follow the steps taken.
Get editable documentsView List

No comments:
Post a Comment
Please don't spam. Comments having links would not be published.