Validation of Pharmaceutical Utilities | GMP Requirements

Utility systems for pharmaceuticals are essential elements for a manufacturing enterprise because they affect product quality and environmental controls. In addition, utilities are also required to operate consistently and reliably under validated conditions to satisfy Good Manufacturing Practices and FDA regulations.

From my experience, many manufacturing deviations have been created not by problems with production equipment, but by problems with poorly controlled utilities. Repeatedly, I have found that inadequate utility systems - such as contaminated water systems, unreliable HVAC systems, oil-laden compressed air, and poor quality steam - have resulted in product failure, excursions in environmental monitoring, and FDA observations throughout the pharmaceutical manufacturing industry.

The validation of utilities is not only a technical component of pharmaceutical quality assurance but also an important part of the strategy for controlling contamination in pharmaceutical manufacturing.

Pharmaceutical companies employ modern utilities to verify that their utility systems perform consistently in accordance with predefined operational and quality requirements during the entire lifecycle of their utilities.

What are Pharmaceutical Utilities?

Manufacturing Support Systems supplied to manufacturers of pharmaceuticals, as well as Environmental Controls and Cleaning, operate equipment, and maintain process reliability by supplying support systems called pharmaceutical utilities or manufacturing utilities. A list of common utilities used within the pharmaceutical industry include:

• Purified Water Systems
• Water for Injection (WFI) Systems
• Clean Steam Systems
• Heating Ventilation Air Conditioning (HVAC) Systems
• Compressed Air Systems
• Process Gases
• Vacuum Systems
• Nitrogen Distribution Systems

Pharmaceutical Utilities may be directly in contact with the product, component and/or manufacturing environment.

Pharmaceutical utilities will be qualified, monitored, maintained and periodically reviewed due to the potential impact on the product manufactured by these utilities.

Importance of Utility Validation

One of the biggest misconceptions about utilities is that they only support manufacturing operations, as such, they have less regulatory scrutiny than production equipment.

The reality is, regulators recognize utilities to be important because failures of utility systems can have consequences such as:

• Product quality
• Sterility warranty
• Environmental control
• Consistency of processes
• Effectiveness of cleaning
• Control of contamination

Examples of this include:

• Microbial contamination in purified water could impact products as contaminated products
• A failure of HVAC systems, would cause clean-room classification to be compromised
• An oil contamination of compressed air may have an impact on both manufacturing equipment & product quality
• Poor quality steam could negatively impact sterilization efficiency

As a result of the above, regulatory agencies perform very thorough evaluations of utility systems during inspections.

Utilities Commonly Requiring Validation

The methods to validate utilities will differ between pharmaceutical facilities based on the type of production that they perform and what the product risk is.

1. Purified Water Systems

Purified water utilities are the most commonly validated utilities in the pharmaceutical manufacturing space. The focus of validation is usually on:

• Chemical quality
• Control of microbials
• Dynamics of flow
• Effectiveness of sanitization
• Control of temperature
• Distribution loop performance

In my experience, water utilities are among the highest incidence of repeat deviations when preventative maintenance and microbial control programs are lacking.

2. Water for Injection Systems (WFI)

WFI systems must undergo a more rigorous method of validation since they are often a component of sterile manufacturing. Significant areas for validation of WFI systems include:

• Temperature maintenance of loops
• Continuous circulation of water
• Performance of distillation or membranes
• Control of endotoxin
• Control of microbial contamination

Regulatory agencies expect to see a significant amount of monitoring and trending associated with WFI systems.

3. HVAC Systems

HVAC systems in pharmaceutical manufacturing areas play a critical role in ensuring the environment is maintained. HVAC systems validation will typically include:

• Airflow visualization
• Integrity testing of HEPA filters
• Temperature mapping
• Humidity control
• Pressure differential
• Air change verification

HVAC systems validation is especially critical in sterile manufacturing facilities.

4. Compressed Air Systems

Compressed air has many applications:

• Operating equipment
• Transferring products
• Cleaning
• Process application

When validating, one must evaluate:

• Particulate levels
• Oil content
• Moisture control
• Microbial quality

One common observation I see is that many companies do not monitor the quality of their compressed air on a regular basis after they have qualified the compressed air supply for initial use.

5. Clean Steam Systems

Clean steam is used for:

• Sterilizing
• SIP systems
• Humidifying

When validating clean steam, one must validate:

• The quality of the condensate
• The presence of non-condensable gases
• The dryness fraction of the steam
• Whether or not it is superheated

If the quality of the clean steam is poor, then the sterilization process may not be effective.

Qualification Stages in Utility Validation

The Lifecycle qualification process for Utilities Validation is the general approach taken for Validation of Utilities

1. Design Qualification (DQ)

The first phase is the Design Qualification (DQ) which verifies whether the proposed utility system design meets the requirements of Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) and operationally. DQ reviews the following documentation, systems & operationally,

• Capacity of systems
• Material compatibility of systems
• Capability of system sanitization
• Design of instrumentation
• Flow characteristics of systems

The biggest problem associated with Utility Validation is poor initial design, which will be extremely hard to correct at a later time.

2. Installation Qualification (IQ)

The second phase is Installation Qualification (IQ), which provides validation that installed utility systems conform to the specifications provided in the approval document. An example of activities found during the Installation Qualification (IQ) process include:

• Piping documentation verification
• Material Certification review
• Instrument Calibration verification
• Utility Connection verification
• Drawing verification

Documentation accuracy during the IQ phase is extremely critical.

3. Operational Qualification (DQ)

Operational Qualification, or OQ, establishes that the utility system functions as per its intended operating ranges. The types of tests performed to establish OQ could include the following:

• Alarm Tests
• Flow Tests
• Temperature Controls
• Pressure Tests
• Sanitization Cycle Assessment

Utilities should be challenged under "worst-case" operating conditions where possible.

4. Performance Qualification (PQ)

Performance Qualification (PQ) establishes that the utility systems consistently perform as intended given actual operating conditions. Some examples include:

• Water Microbial Sampling
• Environmental Monitoring Trends
• Compressed Air Quality Tests
• HVAC Environmental Stability

The typical duration of PQ consists of extended monitoring to establish long term consistency.

Risk-Based Approach in Utility Validation

In the validation of utilities, the application of a risk-based approach is becoming more prevalent. Different utilities require different levels of control. Risk evaluations consider the following factors:

• Potential for product contact
• Impact on sterility
• Potential for contamination
• Criticality to the process
• Impact on patient safety

Utilities that contact sterile product will have much more stringent controls than those that do not contact product.

Utility Monitoring After Validation

Validation should not just happen once. Routine monitoring will help maintain a validated state. Examples of regular monitoring activities include:

• Water Microbial Testing
• Conductivity Monitoring
• Differential Pressure Monitoring
• HVAC Environmental Monitoring
• Compressed Air Testing
• Steam Quality Testing

Trend analysis will be crucial since specifications can be eliminated by gradual deterioration.

Common Utility Validation Problems

There are multiple common recurring validation issues that occur with pharmaceutical utility systems.

1. Inadequate Sanitization Programs

Inadequate controls for sanitization are often responsible for microbial contamination within water systems. Some common issues include:

• Inadequate frequency for completing sanitization
• Non-uniform coverage with sanitation
• Improper concentration of sanitizing chemical
• Formation of dead legs (water stagnation within a given area and creating conditions ideal for the development of bacteria or other microorganisms).

Ongoing microbial control should be exercised on all water systems.

2. Poor Preventative Maintenance

Without an adequate level of preventative maintenance, utility systems can deteriorate prematurely. Some typical problems associated with inadequate preventative maintenance include:

• Pump failures
• Sensor drift
• Air leaks
• HVAC imbalance
• Corrosion issues

Providing preventative maintenance on validated systems has a direct impact on ensuring the validated performance of the respective systems.

3. Dead Legs in Water Systems

Dead legs (stagnant pipe segments), are one of the contributing conditions for the promotion of microbial growth within a water system.

Based on my experience, dead legs are one of the most commonly identified deficiencies during a water system inspection.

If pipe designs are properly constructed, the potential for stagnation is minimized.

4. Inadequate Trending of Utility Systems

Numerous facilities collect utility monitoring data; nonetheless, they do not adequately trend it. By performing trend analysis one can identify:

• Gradual increase in microbial count
• Pressure fluctuations
• Temperature variations
• Deterioration of equipment

Without upward cause evaluation of trends, many of the early warning signs go unnoticed.

5. Data Integrity Concerns in Utility Systems

Utility systems today often have automated monitoring systems. Regulators now monitor:

• Audit trail
• Electronic record
• Alarm management
• Access control
• Backups

Weaknesses in data integrity found in utility monitoring systems can result in serious compliance issues.

6. Revalidation and Change Control

Utility systems typically undergo changes throughout the life cycle of operation. Examples of such changes include:

• Replacement of pumps
• Extension of loops
• HVAC balance change
• Upgrading instruments

All critical changes should be reviewed through formal change control. Partial or complete revalidation may also be required, depending on the risk assessment.

Utility Validation During Regulatory Inspections

Regulatory inspectors will focus on the utility because of the direct relationship of the utility to the control of contamination and the reliability of manufacturing. The inspectors will typically review:

• Qualification Protocols
• Monitoring Data Trends
• Calibration Records
• Maintenance History
• Deviation Investigations
• Alerts and Action Limit Management

I have seen instances where utility system deficiencies resulted in major observations because of weak investigation processes and poor data trend evaluations during multiple inspections.

Documentation Requirements

The completion of utility validation requires extensive documentation for every step of the utility's lifecycle. Some important documents include:

• User Requirement Specifications (URS)
• Qualification Protocols
• Validation Reports
• Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs)
• Monitoring Data
• Calibration Records
• Maintenance Logs

The absence of complete documentation presents Agency regulatory exposure.

Role of Engineering and QA Teams

Utility validation relies heavily on the collaboration between the engineering function and the quality function. The engineering team is typically responsible for:

• Designing activities
• Troubleshooting technical issues
• Maintaining their product
• Optimizing the system

While the QA team typically manages:

• Validation of compliance to good manufacturing practices
• Review of documentation
• Approval of change control
• Managing investigations

Facilities that are weak in cross-functional coordination will often have difficulties in regards to the reliability of the utilities.

Utility Validation Best Practices

A number of practices are typical of organizations with mature utility management systems. 

Best Practice Recommendations:

• Design utility systems utilizing sanitary engineering principles
• Perform risk-based validation planning
• Establish comprehensive preventive maintenance programmes
• Regularly trend-monitor utility data
• Prevent dead leg formation
• Conduct thorough reviews of utility deviations
• Establish strong change control processes

The utility management process cycle should continue throughout the entire life cycle of the facility in order to ensure proper management of all aspects related to utilities.

The verification process helps ensure the quality of production, the consistency of production performance, control of contamination, assurance of product quality, and compliance with regulatory standards. Utility systems such as purified water, HVAC systems, compressed air, clean steam, and process gases have a direct effect on the operation of pharmaceutical manufacturing and, as such, require a structured qualification, monitoring, and lifecycle management approach.

In my opinion, the most successful pharmaceutical manufacturing facilities consider utility validation an ongoing process of operational discipline rather than a one-time qualification event. Successful organizations realize that by incorporating sound engineering design practices, preventive maintenance, risk-based monitoring, reliable data integrity controls, and proactive quality oversight, the facilities will be much better prepared to meet their utility performance and inspection readiness needs in today's highly regulated environment.

Regulatory References

1. FDA Guidance for Industry: Sterile Drug Products Produced by Aseptic Processing
2. EU GMP Annex 1 Manufacture of Sterile Medicinal Products
3. WHO Good Manufacturing Practices Guidelines
4. ISPE Baseline Guide on Commissioning and Qualification

Get ready to use editable Validation Protocols in MS-Word FormatView List

Share

Tweet

Share

Pin it

Share